Best Soccer Betting Sites in New Jersey - Dec 2024

America’s relationship with soccer is interesting. Once the butt of jokes, the picture now looks very different. And, as the popularity of soccer grows, so does the number of people placing wagers.

The continued rise of the beautiful game in the United States along with a passion for the major European leagues, has also helped to drive an increase in betting. In this article, we’ll reveal the best soccer betting sites for fans in New Jersey and assess exactly what makes them stand out. 

We’ll also discuss the different lines available, sportsbook promotions and even some strategies to help improve your win rate.

Best New Jersey Soccer Betting Sites for 2024

Before we get into a deep dive below, above is an overview of the best soccer betting sites in New Jersey right now for 2024.

Our experts have taken our overall rankings and then whittled that down further based on the specific offering for soccer.

What Do the Best Soccer Betting Sites in New Jersey have in Common?

Okay, so you’ve seen the top soccer betting sites in New Jersey. But why have we chosen them? What makes them so good? Well, our expert team analyzes dozens of different criteria. But the very best sportsbooks all share a number of key qualities.

Plenty of Soccer Betting Opportunities

Perhaps it goes without saying, but the best sites for betting on soccer must offer plenty of wagering opportunities. First of all, that means access to games. And not just the biggest leagues and competitions, but minor leagues from around the world too.

Within each game, we want to see dozens, if not hundreds of lines. The moneyline is essential, as are handicap spreads and total goals. But soccer offers more potential prop bets than any other sport. First goalscorer, last goalscorer, scorecasts, stats betting, cards betting, both teams to score… the list is almost endless.

Finally, it’s vital to ensure that your chosen sportsbook offers competitive odds. After all, if you can win more money betting elsewhere, it’s a no brainer to do so. Getting the best value out of a bet outweighs probably every other factor.

Bonuses and Promotions

Speaking of maximizing value, all of New Jersey’s best soccer sportsbooks are packed to the rafters with rewarding promotions. Kick things off with a juicy welcome bonus, such as the four-figure offers found at Caesars or BetMGM. But it’s just as important to check the ongoing rewards for loyal punters.

Whether it’s a structured rewards program, or just plenty of regular free bets, odds boosts and reload bonuses, regular promotions are integral to a successful sportsbook. We’ll talk more about the types of bonus found at the best soccer betting sites in the Garden State later. 

Player Protection and Security

The final thing that all quality sportsbooks share is a commitment to player safety. You’re probably thinking of things like SSL encryption, to protect your deposits and withdrawals. Or two-factor authentication, to keep nefarious actors out of your account.

Those things are great to see, but there’s more to it than that. First of all, every soccer betting site in New Jersey should be licensed by the state’s Division of Gaming Enforcement. That ensures each company is run by honest people who will ring fence player funds and carry out industry best practices.

In addition, there should be strict verification processes, to help keep underage gamblers safe from harm. And of course, a range of responsible gambling tools goes a long way to help look after the small percentage of people who can develop a harmful relationship with sports betting.

Convenient Banking Options and Payment Methods

You can’t bet on soccer without money. Which is why the top sites for betting in New Jersey offer plenty of convenient deposit and withdrawal options. Debit and credit cards, provided by reputable processors like Visa and American Express, should be the absolute minimum.

On top of that, we like to see fast and reliable ewallets, as well as traditional banking options to keep the old school bettors happy. Bank wires, e-checks and even cash should all be available to use. Finally, it’s equally important to move with the times, so there’s always brownie points for modern technology like Apple Pay.

Aside from the range of payment methods, it’s necessary to check the terms and conditions. How high, if any, are the transaction fees? What are the minimum deposit and withdrawal amounts? Top sportsbooks keep things reasonable to include everyone, regardless of bankroll. 

What Makes a Great Soccer Betting Product?

Aside from these shared attributes, several other factors help the best soccer betting sites stand out from the crowd. Let’s take a look at a few of the most crucial considerations.

Watch and Wager - Live Streaming in New Jersey

If you don’t want to spend money on expensive sports broadcast packages, joining a betting site can offer a cheaper alternative. Simply fund your account and place a small bet on the action and you’ll have access to dozens of streams every day. 

Not all sportsbooks offer it, but we list all those that do within their respective betting site reviews.

Stats the Way We Like It - Live Data Plays a Big Part in Soccer Betting

There are more games than ever to bet on, but they’re often in far-flung corners of the world. We can’t all be experts in the Venezuelan Primera División, or Sweden’s Superettan, for instance. That’s why it’s vital that the best soccer sportsbooks supply plenty of useful stats and data to get stuck into before betting.

Cash Out Wagers as the Match Unfolds

Cash out adds a new dimension to betting on the beautiful game. Is your team holding onto a narrow lead in the final minutes? Then it’s probably a good idea to lock in those profits and watch the remainder of the game in peace. Of course, cash out is also a useful feature for minimizing losses, if you change your mind early into the game.

Live Soccer Betting Sites in New Jersey

Wagers during a game now make up the majority of an online sportsbook’s business. The rise in smartphone usage, coupled with better internet connections, drove up the demand for in-play, or “live” betting. 

Bookmakers responded by pouring money into developing improved live betting interfaces, with more streams, stats and markets. The experience is now better than ever, so it’s no surprise to see so much growth in this area. 

Still, the best soccer betting sites continue to innovate with their live product. bet365 is the world’s leading soccer sportsbook when it comes to live betting, and its New Jersey site is excellent. 

You’ll find upwards of 50 in-play soccer betting events, many of which feature live streams, even on the quietest of days. On weekends, when the major European leagues are active, you’re looking at thousands of games, each with dozens, if not hundreds of live betting opportunities. 

Parlay Betting and Soccer

A key feature of all the best soccer betting sites is parlay betting. Those available in New Jersey are certainly no exception, and each one allows you to add multiple picks to the same bet slip.

Parlays are among the most commonly played bet types, as we all love the idea of turning a few cents into a significant chunk of change. The idea is simple. With every additional selection, the odds increase. However, all of them must win and, if just one lets you down, all bets are off. 

The math behind a parlay is simple. Use the initial stake and the odds from the first pick to work out your returns as usual. Whatever the result, this becomes the new stake to calculate the returns from the second pick. Repeat for all selections to get the final payout.

Of course, it’s much easier to simply use an online odds calculator. 

Common Soccer Betting Bonuses for New Jersey Players

All of the world’s best betting sites, not just those in the Garden State, know how to look after their customers. Bonuses play a particularly big role in this, of course. Here are some of the most common soccer-related betting promos found in New Jersey.

Bet and Get

To attract new business, the best sportsbooks in New Jersey hand out lots of free bets to new registrants. At both DraftKings and FanDuel, for instance, you’ll receive $150 worth of free bets if your first bet of at least $5 wins.

That’s right – you only have to risk $5 of real money to potentially pocket $150. So, if you’re a true soccer betting expert, this is a great way to kick off your relationship with a new sportsbook site.

Second Chance Bets

Some of the biggest welcome bonuses available to soccer bettors in the state are second chance bets. Take BetMGM, for instance. Join today and there’s a potential bonus bet worth $1,500 if your first real money wager loses.

Caesars, ESPN Bet and Hard Rock Bet all offer a similar welcome bonus, albeit with varying amounts up for grabs.

Early Payouts

The beautiful game is one of the most dramatic sports in the world. Since games are often low-scoring, the value of a single goal is huge. Few things, therefore, are more annoying than watching your team blow a comfortable two goal cushion to tie, or even lose a game.

That’s why the best soccer betting sites pay out the second your team takes a two goal lead, protecting you from potentially crushing disappointment. It doesn’t matter whether it happens in the 2nd minute, or the 92nd minute; a two goal lead means you’ll bank your returns immediately.

bet365 is most closely associated with this special promotion having pioneered it in Europe, and they offer early payouts on most top sports.

Parlay Boosts and Insurance

As we mentioned, parlays are one of the most popular ways to place soccer bets. Because they’re frustratingly tough to land, many of the top betting sites in New Jersey offer additional incentive and protections for punters. 

Parlay boosts are a common bonus, where the returns are increased by a fixed percentage whenever you win. The more picks you added to the bet, the greater the reward. Some sportsbooks offer as much as 70% on top.

An alternative parlay promotion is to go the other way, providing a consolation prize for a near miss. If just one leg of the parlay fails, you might find yourself in line for a free bet to help soften the blow.

Major Soccer Tournaments for Betting

There are literally hundreds of league and cup competitions around the world, both at domestic and international level. In this section, we’ll highlight the best soccer betting competitions available for betting in New Jersey.

Champions League Soccer Betting

Formerly known as the European Cup, a 1992 rebrand took UEFA’s premier competition to new heights. You’ll consistently see some of the continent’s biggest and most historic teams facing off head to head. 

Look out for the likes of Real Madrid, Barcelona, Juventus, Liverpool and Bayern Munich. Betting on the Champions League opens up a completely different knowledge base than just a single domestic league.

English Premier League Betting

The most popular soccer league in the world, England’s Premier League is home to some huge clubs. Passionate supporters and many of the world’s star players contribute to what is now a truly global affair. 

In the United States, more than two million people watched the crucial Manchester City vs Arsenal game live in April 2024.

Betting on the MLS in New Jersey

America’s own domestic league has grown massively since its launch in 1996. In 2025, there will be a total of 30 teams involved in Major League Soccer, three of which are based in Canada. 

Although Lionel Messi’s move to Inter Miami stole headlines, many other huge soccer names have contributed to its growth and popularity. David Beckham, Zlatan Ibrahimovic, Thierry Henry and Wayne Rooney are just a few examples.

Soccer World Cup Betting in NJ

The biggest prize on the international stage is the World Cup. Organized every four years by FIFA, the United States hosted the showpiece event back in 1994. This sparked a steady surge in soccer’s popularity that has spilled over into the sports betting world. 

In the women’s game, there’s also a World Cup competition every four years. The USA is the most dominant team by far, lifting the trophy on four different occasions. All of the best soccer betting sites now offer odds for women’s games.

Most Common Soccer Betting Markets

When choosing the best soccer sportsbooks in New Jersey, make sure they offer a diverse range of lines. Here are some of the most popular betting opportunities on the beautiful game.

Match Result - the 1X2

While most US sports adopt a simple moneyline, soccer’s European roots mean that it’s possible for the game to end as a tie. That’s why you’ll normally see three options when betting on the winner of the match: the home team, the away team and a tie.

Traditionally called the 1x2 market, the match result is by far the most simple line to wager on within soccer.

Both Teams To Score

Wagering on both teams to score in a game is a real favorite with soccer punters. It doesn’t matter if one team is a huge favorite, and there are no complicated handicaps to overcome.

If both teams score in the game, your bet’s a winner. Although it’s possible to choose “No”, most people back “Yes” as you’ll have an interest in the game until it’s over.

Goalscorer Lines

Another popular way to bet on the beautiful game is to try and guess who’ll score the game’s first goal. With so many players to choose from, the odds can be pretty rewarding, especially if it’s a defensive player. The best soccer betting sites also offer betting on the last goalscorer, as well as players scoring any time during the 90 minutes.

New Jersey Soccer Parlays - Bigger Odds and Bigger Value

Whilst all of the above markets are fantastic ways to wager on soccer, rolling up a number of individual bets into a parlay is, in our opinion, even better as it spreads the excitement over a longer period, ramps up the odds pricing quite high and at pace, and gives players the chance to have a really good payday from lower stakes.

That said, remember that all lines and selections need to win in order to get paid out, so there's definitely more risk built in too.

Top Soccer Betting Strategies

Before we round off our guide to betting on soccer in New Jersey, here are a few top tips to help improve your results.

Back Slow Starting Favorites In-Play

Whenever there’s a huge favorite against a big underdog, there can be value in betting live. Imagine a big team like Manchester City playing away from home against a club that’s scrapping for survival. 

The home team will be fired up and could easily come out of the blocks at pace. It’s not impossible that they might score an early goal. Even if they don’t, the line could still move enough during the opening stages that the inevitable City victory suddenly looks like great value. 

Bet on Ties

This is a simple one, but many soccer bettors are just fans backing their own team to win. The rest are mostly casual punters betting on the favorite to win. Nobody backs the draw, which means the price can be out of line.

Look out for teams that are evenly matched and slated to play each other. Ideally, both teams would be struggling for goals and out of form, making the chance of a low-scoring game more likely.

Study Set Plays

Some teams are exceptionally good from free kicks and corners. Make sure you stay on top of the stats to spot potential sources of value. If a team is particularly well drilled and creating lots of high quality chances for set plays, consider playing the goalscorer markets.

Defenders are usually assigned generous odds to score the first goal. But big center backs are most likely to get on the end of a good delivery from a corner. Make sure you know which players are responsible for taking free kicks and penalties, as their chances of scoring naturally increases.

Conclusion - NJ has an Incredible Amount of Soccer Betting Sites

Soccer is more popular than it’s ever been in the United States. With the World Cup returning to the continent in 2026, all projections suggest that the growth is only going to continue. There’s no doubt that we’ll also see a similar trend when it comes to betting on the beautiful game, as a result.

In the meantime, the best soccer betting sites in New Jersey already offer an excellent experience. With thousands of lines available every day, competitive odds and all kinds of rewarding bonuses, there’s no reason not to join the party.

FAQs