Best Baseball Betting Sites in New Jersey Dec 2024

It’s no surprise to learn that baseball is one of the country’s most popular sports from a betting perspective.

Residents of the NJ enjoy betting as much as anyone else, and they’re spoiled for choice in terms of legal baseball sportsbooks.

Below, aside from highlighting the best baseball betting sites in New Jersey, we’ll also explain some of the most popular markets and features that they offer. And, before we wrap things up, we’ll also share a few tips to help you improve your baseball betting results.

Best Baseball Betting Sites for 2024

To begin with, let’s run through the full list of baseball betting sites in New Jersey, as you'll see in our ranking table above.

What Do the Best Baseball Betting Sites Offer?

Wondering how we ranked these baseball sportsbooks? Well, there’s plenty to consider, and we’re happy to talk about it. 

First things first, all great sportsbooks share a number of common features, no matter what you’re betting on. They must be legal and properly licensed, of course, as safety is the utmost priority. You’ll also want to see several convenient payment options and lots of regular bonuses.

However, if you’d like to bet on baseball in New Jersey, you’re going to need plenty of interesting wagering opportunities, with competitive odds. 

Baseball Betting Opportunities

The best baseball bookies supply plenty of games for punters to get their teeth into. Naturally, MLB matches are always the most popular, so detailed coverage of this particular competition is a non-negotiable.

However, there are plenty of other big baseball leagues around the world, including Japan, Australia, South Korea and Mexico. If your chosen sportsbook doesn’t allow you to bet on these games, it can’t realistically claim to be among the best.

It’s not only about the volume of games, of course. Within each fixture, we’re looking for depth. The top sites offer dozens of lines per event. You’ll find everything from the number of strikeouts thrown and home runs hit, to the correct score and individual team totals.

Baseball Bonuses and Promotions

We all love to receive something for nothing, and in such a competitive industry, betting sites have to give us just that. With so many excellent baseball betting sites available in the New Jersey, nobody is ever going to choose one that doesn’t offer a signup incentive.

It’s not all about welcome bonuses, though. The top bookmakers understand how to look after their most loyal players. We only recommend sites that provide regular reload bonuses, as well as rewarding promotions like odds boosts, bet and gets, or early payouts. 

Ideally, the site will also have some kind of structured loyalty program, where you earn points and perks as you place bets. 

Safety and Security

Every baseball betting site in New Jersey must possess a license from the Division of Gaming Enforcement, better-known as the DGE. This guarantees that they’re operating within the law, as the regulator constantly audits each sportsbook. 

Your money will be looked after carefully, while industry best practices around responsible gambling, game integrity and security are sure to be followed.

Payment Options

You can’t place a single bet on baseball without first funding your sportsbook wallet. That’s why the best baseball betting sites make our lives as easy as they can, providing the widest possible range of banking methods.

Whether you prefer ewallets, debit cards or mobile options like Apple Pay, there’s something for everyone at our recommended sportsbooks. What’s more, we check the terms and conditions to make sure there are no sneaky fees buried in the fine print. 

Finally, it’s important to consider the minimum and maximum deposit and withdrawal limits of each payment option. High deposit limits exclude those of us with smaller bankrolls, which is never a good thing.

What Makes a Good Baseball Betting Product?

In addition to the above attributes, New Jersey’s best betting sites offer a number of baseball-specific features to help their products stand out.

Live betting and an intuitive mobile app are “must haves” for all sportsbooks these days. But those sites which really stand out are stuffed with all kinds of goodies to help enhance your baseball betting experience, including live streams, cashout and insightful statistics. 

Watch the Action Without Expensive Subscriptions

MLB.TV isn’t cheap, but there’s no reason to miss a minute of the action thanks to New Jersey’s best sportsbook sites. Live streams are provided for all of the biggest games, with many others from around the world.

FanDuel is one of the best options for live baseball streams, though BetMGM is pretty good too. Depending on your chosen site, you might not even have to bet on the game to watch the stream. Just make sure you have funds in your account.

Moneyball

Baseball is one of the most stats-heavy sports of all, which is why the top sportsbooks offer tons of data to help inform your picks. Whether it’s pre-game statistics, or the live box score, everything you need to bet is right at your fingertips.

It’s not just lists of facts and figures, either. The best sites provide all kinds of cool visualizations to indicate what’s happening on the field.

Don’t Strike Out – Cash Out

Technology like cash out gives the modern bettor a chance to adjust wagers while they’re still live. By selling your bet at any time, you can lock in a guaranteed profit before the game is over. It’s even possible to salvage what’s left of a bet that’s gone awry, before losing the entire stake.

The best baseball sportsbook for this is probably Fanatics, due to the partial cash out option. Here, you can elect to sell a percentage of the bet, letting the rest ride. This innovation gives you more control than ever before.

Common Baseball Betting Bonuses for NJ Players

A significant marker of a good baseball betting site is the selection of bonuses and promotions. In this section of our guide, we’ll run through the most common offers that punters can take advantage of in the Garden State. 

No Sweat First Bet Bonuses

The big-name sportsbooks in New Jersey offer some ridiculously generous welcome bonuses. DraftKings is a notable example, giving you a sort of refund on your first real money bet up to a massive $1,500.

That’s right – open a new account and if your first baseball wager loses, they’ll return the stake back in the form of bonus bets. 

Bet and Get

An alternative welcome offer from some sportsbooks in New Jersey is the Bet and Get. However, this type of promotion is sometimes available to all bettors, not only new registrants.

It’s pretty much exactly what it sounds like, too, with no significant strings attached. The only caveat is that your bet has to win.

At FanDuel, for instance, all you need to do is place a real money bet of at least $5. If that wager comes in, you’ll receive $150 worth of bonuses, just like that. 

Early Payouts

bet365 has earned a reputation in the Garden State for its generous early payout promos. It’s not unique to baseball, as they run similar offers for soccer, basketball and other sports too. However, baseball fans simply love this promotion.

If your pick goes ahead by five runs or more in any game, they instantly settle the bet as a winner. Even if your team goes on to lose, it doesn’t matter, as you’ve already been paid. How good is that?

Parlay Insurance

If you’re a fan of placing baseball parlays, you’ll want to look out for insurance promotions. We all know how tricky it can be to land a bet containing multiple picks. And it’s heartbreaking when you miss out on a huge score because one team let you down.

Well, thanks to parlay insurance, that hammer blow can be significantly cushioned. If just one leg of your bet costs you a win, there will be some sort of consolation prize. That usually means having the stake refunded as a bonus bet. 

DraftKings sometimes runs this type of promotion, so keep your eyes peeled.

Major Baseball Tournaments for Betting

Baseball may be America’s game, but it’s played all around the world. Here are some of the best competitions for betting that all top sportsbooks in New Jersey should be offering.  

MLB

Major League Baseball, or simply MLB, is by far the biggest league in the world. It’s made up of two distinct competitions – the National League and the American League – which came together in 1903 to form the world’s oldest professional sports league.

Mexican Baseball League

Founded in 1928, the Liga Mexicana de Béisbol, or LMB, boasts 20 teams and a 114 game regular season. It is the country’s oldest professional sports league, and televised games regularly draw between two and three million viewers. Known for the passionate supporters and colorful road jerseys, every game is a genuine spectacle. 

Nippon Professional Baseball

Japan loves to play baseball, and the NPB features 12 of the country’s elite teams. Founded back in 1949, it boasts a rich history, and baseball was the nation’s only professional sport until 1993. Unfortunately, the NPB has struggled with financial problems in recent years. This hasn’t been helped by its star players leaving for MLB teams.

Korean Baseball Organization

Formed in 1982 with just six teams, the KBO has since expanded to ten. Since 2015, each regular season features 144 games, with each team playing every other organization a total of 16 times. This creates plenty of action on which punters can place bets.

Most Common Baseball Betting Markets

Although the best baseball sportsbooks in New Jersey offer dozens of betting opportunities per game, there are three which stand out. Let’s take a look at the most popular lines and how they work.

Run Line

The most popular baseball betting market is the run line, where a handicap is applied to the favorite. If you bet on the underdog, you’ll receive a head start, which helps to keep things more interesting. Naturally, the odds are moved closer together to compensate.

For example, if your pick has a +1.5 advantage on the run line, they can lose by one run and your bet still wins.

Moneyline

All of the best baseball betting sites in New Jersey offer a moneyline, as it’s the most simple way to gamble on the sport. Just pick whichever team you think will win the game, with no need to factor in handicaps or combined totals. 

There can be wide discrepancies between the teams in terms of odds, if one is a heavy favorite. But the simplicity of the moneyline makes it a preference of many bettors.

Totals

With this market, the aim is to guess whether the total number of runs scored will be higher or lower than a fictional line. The bookies will provide a figure, for example 8.5, and you bet over or under that value.

Remember, this is a total figure, so you’ll need to combine the runs scored by both teams. A final result of 5-3 means that “under” bets win in the aforementioned example, as 8 is less than the 8.5 line.

Live Betting at Baseball Sportsbooks in New Jersey

Betting in-play is bigger than it’s ever been, and New Jersey’s best baseball betting sites understand its popularity. They offer user-friendly live betting consoles, with odds that update quickly and reliably. Not to mention reams of stats, game trackers and streams so that you can follow the action.

Live betting opens up a whole new set of unique bet types, giving you more chances to wager and win. It also offers real baseball experts the opportunity to capitalize on their knowledge in real time.

Parlay Betting and Baseball

All of New Jersey’s best baseball betting sites accept parlays, as this is also one of the most popular ways to bet. 

By combining multiple picks into a single wager, you greatly increase your potential returns. That’s because the odds are multiplied together, giving you a much greater price than if you back each pick individually. 

Let’s say you wanted to back both the Mets and the Yankees to win, at odds of +105 and -145 respectively. Two bets of $50 each would return $102.50 and $84.48, for a total payout of $186.98.

However, a single $100 parlay would result in a payout of $346.38, which is almost double that of the two singles. 

It’s not hard to see why this way of betting on baseball is popular. Of course, the flip side is that such bets are much harder to win, so proceed with caution. 

Top Baseball Betting Strategies

You’re almost ready to go, but before you place your first real money baseball bets, take heed of the following advice. 

Underdogs Can Bite

In baseball, upsets are not rare. Look out for two teams playing a series of three or four games in quick succession, as happens a lot in the MLB. 

You can often find valuable opportunities to back the underdog when the favorite is resting a star player. Similarly, if the team has suffered a long trip and might be tired, there can be value in opposing them.

Weather or Not

The weather won’t dictate the result of a baseball game in the same way it might a horse race, or a soccer game. But it can have a huge impact on certain markets, like betting on run totals.

Wind is an obvious consideration, as strong gusts will make things trickier for hitters. Rain could lead to a game ending early, which favors under bets. While high temperatures cause the ball to travel further.

Ditch the Parlays

Baseball is a famously high-variance game, where any team can beat another. So, if you’re serious about betting on the sport, you should consider throwing parlays into the trash.

They’re certainly great fun and promise sizeable returns. But when you place a parlay, you’re simply multiplying the bookmaker’s built-in mathematical edge.

Conclusion

Baseball is extremely popular in the USA, both in terms of viewing figures and betting handle. 

As one of the four major professional leagues in the country, it’s vital that a sportsbook offers plenty of MLB lines. However, the best baseball betting sites also cover leagues that are much further afield, including Mexico, Australia and in Asia.

All of the sites featured in this guide do exactly that. What’s more, they offer a vast selection of markets for each game, supported by live streams and innovative features. Join one today to see for yourself.

FAQs